This Thing, is it Right? How do I Tell?

(Photo credit: heathbrandon)

We’ve had several threads around here recently that got me thinking about a subject near and dear my heart: how we evaluate information. Especially information about Pagan ‘stuff’, where we’re talking about a mix of personal experience, academic research, shared knowledge (and sometimes all three in the same sentence.)

So. How do you sort the useful from the problematic?

Do you do things differently depending on the source? (I certainly handle, say, a book from a known source differently than, say, an entirely unknown new poster on this forum.)

I have lots of ideas on this, but I want to sit on my hands and let other people get started and ask questions about stuff for a bit first.